Exploring Faith, Culture, and Connection
Bridging Worlds, Through Grace, Truth and Dialogue.
By Dr. Tim Orr
In recent years, the resurgence of antisemitism has reached what can only be described as tsunami proportions. This hatred, long a fixture of human history, has taken on new and insidious forms woven into the language of activism, justice, and human rights. Today, we see thousands marching in the streets of Western cities, chanting slogans that equate Israel to Nazi Germany, accusing it of genocide, and calling for its destruction. Such claims are not only grotesque distortions but outright lies. For instance, Gaza’s population has increased annually (CIA Factbook, 2023), undermining the narrative of “genocide.” Yet these falsehoods are embraced and amplified by media outlets, academic institutions, and political actors.
This tidal wave of Jew hatred is no accident. It has been carefully cultivated over decades, fueled by a mix of historical prejudices, political ideologies, and a dangerous alignment between the Palestinian cause and Western progressive movements. As Melanie Phillips (2024) aptly notes in her article, The Truth of the Palestinian Cause, this alignment is not based on facts or justice but on a shared disdain for Israel and a willingness to rewrite history to fit a narrative of oppression.
Antisemitism: A Historical Continuum
Antisemitism has always been a persistent undercurrent in global history. From the blood libels of medieval Europe to the racial pseudoscience of the Nazis, Jews have long been scapegoats for society’s fears and failures. What makes today’s iteration of antisemitism particularly insidious is its modern guise. No longer is it confined to fringe hate groups or overtly discriminatory regimes; instead, it is embedded in mainstream discourse, often disguised as legitimate criticism of Israel.
As Phillips (2024) argues, this transformation did not happen overnight. It has been cultivated by decades of Palestinian propaganda, which positions the Jewish state as the ultimate oppressor and Palestinians as eternal victims. Palestinian Authority (PA) officials and media outlets regularly disseminate grotesque lies about Jews. Sermons and broadcasts accuse Jews of controlling the media, orchestrating global conspiracies, and committing atrocities reminiscent of ancient blood libels (Palestinian Media Watch, 2023).
These narratives are not marginal. They are institutionalized within Palestinian society, taught in schools, aired on state-sponsored media, and preached from pulpits. As Melanie Phillips (2024) highlights, these lies are not just weapons of propaganda but foundational elements of the Palestinian cause. They perpetuate a culture of hatred that makes peace impossible and justifies violence against Jews as a moral imperative.
The West’s Complicity
Perhaps most disturbing is the West’s role in amplifying these narratives. Progressive movements, which pride themselves on championing human rights and equality, have paradoxically become some of the loudest proponents of antisemitic tropes. The Palestinian cause has been elevated as a symbol of resistance against colonialism and oppression despite being rooted in genocidal rhetoric and a categorical rejection of coexistence with Israel. This hypocrisy is further underscored by the fact that Islam, the dominant religion in the Arab world, is inherently colonialist and imperialist—having spread through conquest and the subjugation of other cultures throughout history. This selective outrage against alleged colonialism while ignoring the imperialist legacy of Islam exposes a glaring double standard in progressive discourse.
Phillips (2024) notes that ideological shifts in Western politics have driven this alignment. Left-wing governments, eager to appease growing Muslim constituencies and align with the broader anti-colonial narrative, have uncritically adopted Palestinian propaganda. This is evident in countries like Britain, Canada, and Australia, where political leaders parrot accusations of apartheid and genocide without regard for their veracity (Smith, 2023).
Academia and media have also played a pivotal role. Universities that once championed free thought now censor voices that defend Israel or critique Palestinian narratives. Media outlets, eager to align with progressive causes, amplify unverified claims against Israel while downplaying or ignoring Palestinian incitement. As Phillips (2024) observes, this Orwellian distortion of truth has created an environment where antisemitism is not only tolerated but celebrated as a form of social justice.
The Role of Palestinian Propaganda
The central driver of this tsunami of Jew hatred remains Palestinian propaganda. Over decades, Palestinian leaders have crafted a narrative that not only vilifies Israel but dehumanizes Jews as a whole. This is not merely a political strategy but a deeply ingrained cultural and ideological framework. As Melanie Phillips (2024) emphasizes, the Palestinian cause is not rooted in a desire for statehood but in the eradication of Jewish sovereignty and the demonization of Jews.
This propaganda is pervasive. From school textbooks that glorify martyrs who kill Jews to sermons that call for their extermination “for the sake of Allah,” the Palestinian leadership has institutionalized antisemitism. Organizations like MEMRI and Palestinian Media Watch have documented these patterns extensively, showing how hatred of Jews is not an aberration but a cornerstone of Palestinian identity (Palestinian Media Watch, 2023).
The Hypocrisy of Progressive Antisemitism
One of the most tragic aspects of this crisis is the complicity of progressive movements in perpetuating antisemitism. These movements, which claim to stand for equality and justice, have aligned themselves with the Palestinian cause without critically examining its underlying ideologies. They ignore the genocidal rhetoric of Palestinian leaders, the systemic indoctrination of hate, and the rejection of peace initiatives.
Phillips (2024) argues that this hypocrisy stems from a broader moral inversion within progressive politics. By framing Jews as oppressors and Palestinians as victims, progressives have created a binary narrative that leaves no room for nuance or truth. This has led to absurdities such as labeling Israel, a democratic state, as an apartheid regime while excusing or ignoring the authoritarianism and corruption of Palestinian leadership.
The Call to Confront the Lies
Confronting this tsunami of Jew hatred requires a multifaceted approach. First, the lies must be exposed and countered with truth. Organizations like MEMRI and Palestinian Media Watch play a crucial role in documenting and disseminating the reality of Palestinian incitement. Scholars and activists must amplify these truths, challenging the narratives that dominate media and academia.
Second, a concerted effort must hold governments and institutions accountable. Political leaders who repeat baseless accusations against Israel must be challenged. Universities and cultural institutions that censor pro-Israel voices or tolerate antisemitism must be confronted.
Finally, the Jewish community itself must stand united. As Phillips (2024) notes, some Jews have internalized the false narratives of their oppressors, advocating for policies that undermine Israel and ignoring the antisemitism at the heart of the Palestinian cause. This internal division weakens the fight against Jew hatred and emboldens its proponents.
Conclusion
The tsunami of Jew-hatred engulfing the world today is not an isolated phenomenon; it is the culmination of decades of lies, propaganda, and moral failures. As Melanie Phillips (2024) writes, this crisis is as much about the West’s complicity as it is about Palestinian incitement. Confronting it requires courage, truth, and a commitment to justice that transcends political ideology. The stakes are too high for silence or inaction. The time to act is now, before history repeats itself in even darker and more tragic ways.
References
CIA Factbook. (2023). Gaza population data. Retrieved from https://www.cia.gov
MEMRI. (2023). Monitoring antisemitic rhetoric in Palestinian media. Retrieved from https://www.memri.org
Palestinian Media Watch. (2023). Antisemitic incitement in Palestinian Authority broadcasts. Retrieved from https://www.palwatch.org
Phillips, M. (2024). The truth of the Palestinian cause. Jerusalem Chronicle. December 31, 2024.
Smith, J. (2023). The West's complicity in the normalization of antisemitism. Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 25(4), 345-367.
Tim Orr is a scholar of Islam, Evangelical minister, conference speaker, and interfaith consultant with over 30 years of experience in cross-cultural ministry. He holds six degrees, including a master’s in Islamic studies from the Islamic College in London. Tim taught Religious Studies for 15 years at Indiana University Columbus and is now a Congregations and Polarization Project research associate at the Center for the Study of Religion and American Culture at Indiana University Indianapolis. He has spoken at universities, including Oxford University, Imperial College London, the University of Tehran, Islamic College London, and mosques throughout the U.K. His research focuses on American Evangelicalism, Islamic antisemitism, and Islamic feminism, and he has published widely, including articles in Islamic peer-reviewed journals and three books.
Sign up for Dr. Tim Orr's Blog
Dr. Tim Orr isn't just your average academic—he's a passionate advocate for interreligious dialogue, a seasoned academic, and an ordained Evangelical minister with a unique vision.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.